Where am I?  > Home >  Blog Post > Legal Village

A barrister like Wills and other useless qualifications

Author: Alex Aldridge

08 Jul 2009 | 01:00 | 4 comments

The news that Prince William has been made an honorary barrister has provoked some annoyed responses - the flames of disgruntled public opinion fanned by William's decision to include a trademark Windsor gag in his acceptance speech.
 
"I promise not to practise, except for the odd speeding ticket," quipped the heir to the throne as he addressed the Middle Temple earlier this week.
 
This little flourish was the final straw for Guardian 'Comment is free' w riter Heather McRobie, who wrote in response: "To allow - even theoretically, even 'jokingly' - unqualified individuals like William to practise undermines everything the profession stands for. Would we make someone an honorary medical doctor? An honorary teacher?"
 
For Heather, I've got some reassuring news: William won't be allowed to practise - even to handle those speeding tickets. Being able to call yourself a 'barrister' and being able to practise as a barrister are, as I've found out the hard way, two very different things.
 
As a graduate of the Bar Vocational Course (BVC), I share with William the dubious honour of being able to call myself a 'barrister'. But as one of the many who tried and failed to get a pupillage, practising as a barrister would result in my likely incarceration - or at least a hefty fine. Our future king would, in theory, face the same sanction.
 
The point I'm trying to make is that the title of barrister was de-valued a long time before they gave it to Wills. For years now, BVC providers have welcomed law graduates with open arms and the promise that whatever happens, even if they don't get a pupillage (and only one in four do), they'll still get 'Called to the Bar' at the end of it and be able to call themselves barristers.
 
Well, a few words of wisdom for prospective BVC students: if you're plan ning on doing the course so you can stick 'barrister' after your name on your CV and wow pe ople at dinner parties with your new title, you might want to think again. Like William, you won't be impressing anyone. I ended up getting into journalism, which in my hearts of hearts was what I think I really wanted to do, partly by writing about my experiences trying to get a pupillage, so the BVC wasn't a complete waste. But when I last checked, the BVC cost almost £15,000 and a NCTJ journalism course around £3,000.

esr-static

  • Comment
  • News alerts
  • Share
  • Print
  • RSS
  • Linkedin

COMMENTS (TOTAL 4 COMMENTS)

I don't think the point is whether he can practise or not. The point is that there are thousands of people spending thousands of pounds a year WORKING for the title of "barrister", and this yahoo is gifted it because of an accident of birth. Doesn't this rather negate all the subscription fees going into widening access to the Bar?

Values are what you do - not what you say you do. We now know that Middle Temple values aristocracy over meritocracy.

All I can say is that I'm glad I don't belong to Middle Temple.

Anonymous -09 Jul 2009 | 01:00

A good point well made.

Anonymous -10 Jul 2009 | 01:00

Ha ha ha. One day we might have a royal capable of achieving higher than ABC at A-level after attending one of the most expensive public schools around the world. He or she might even attend Oxbridge or a Russell Group university. Until that day we just have to acknowledge that we are being "ruled" by undereducated muppets.

Pete jones -13 Jul 2009 | 01:00

Great article. You would have been wasted at the bar (or perhaps if the stereotypes are true that is exactly what you get up to now that you are a journalist).

Taking cheques from thousands of aspiring barristers to do the BVC when there is little hope of a pupillage at the end of it is cynical in the extreme. When I went to Bar School there was a scramble for pupillages and the majority on the course didn't get one. Of those of us who did probably 1 in 4 actually got a tenancy, but at least those who complete pupillage have a good chance of another legal job.

Reader -16 Jul 2009 | 01:00

Post Comment

Advertisement

Advertisement

SERVICES SECTION

Legal Week Law

Legal briefings

Sign up to Legal Week Law to receive legal briefings from the world's leading law firms. Click here for more info

Legal Week Reports

Company profiles

Legal Week Reports gives busy law professionals direct access to reliable company profiles - ideal for maintaining knowledge on existing clients and gaining insight on potential new clients. Click here for more info

LinkedIn

In-house Lawyers Group

Legal Week's LinkedIn group for in-house lawyers, which now has over 4,200 members, acts as a networking tool for senior in-house counsel to discuss key issues affecting their roles. Click here to join the group

Twitter

Follow Legal Week on twitter

Legal Week's Twitter feed, which now has more than 25,000 followers, features a selection of the latest news, opinion, blogs and links to interesting articles from the world of law. Click here for more information

Legal Week on the iPad

New interactive iPad app

Legal Week has launched a new, fully interactive, version of its iPad app. Subscribers to the magazine can download the app and read weekly issues at no extra cost. Click here for more information